You Can See Everything (2026)
I have this bizarre relationship with film wherewith I barely watch any - too long, requires too much attention, can't sit still - and yet every film I see I want to talk about. I really didn't want to write about this. But anyway.
Spoilers but not really, I don't give away the specific plotting of the film.
From the jump, "You Can See Everything" kinda fucked with me. I hardly understand why people with infamous reputations would want to reveal themselves, though I understand psychologically why: they do not perceive themselves as having done anything wrong, and, because they cannot refute the evidence they are wrong, they seek to reveal themselves so as to demonstrate "their" truth. Which reveals that they have no concept of truth whatsoever, and that is what they want to show, even though they don't realize it initially: that they don't believe in the truth and they also want the audience to unlearn the truth or "truth" as well. If you cannot demonstrate, you re-educate. It's actually quite logical, though people who lie don't understand the mechanism of logic well ("well" being the operative word; they cannot understand the logic of a neutral person).
This I'm quite convinced of: one of the reasons people lie or engage in hypocrisy is because the outcome they desire is greater than the guilt they feel. And this strikes me as the case with Elizabeth Holmes: she seems completely incapable of feeling guilt. And this does not make her a bad person. She is, in fact, mentally unwell. Like many of the audience, and like Nathan Fielder and Amanda Seyfried evidently, I could not tell when she was lying. But I know she doesn't feel bad when she says something less than the truth. There is a wonderful line of inquiry where she and Fielder discuss big lies and little lies - I get the impression she knows what a lie is and is not, but the bigness and littleness of a lie are concepts she is absolutely unconcerned with. You can brush off little lies, you can defend little lies, you can get upset over little lies; there is no distinction to the magnitude of a lie because Holmes doesn't reflect on her lies. She can be genuinely upset about the consequences of her actions - which consequences are, the loss of her assets and the damage to her reputation - but she cannot understand what is "deserved" about these consequences, that detector is simply not there.
But that's the puzzling and kinda the messed-up effect "You Can See Everything" has on the viewer: can we really characterize Elizabeth Holmes, even after this documentary? One of the themes of the doc is, we don't know when Holmes is lying, and Holmes doesn't seem to know she is lying, or she is so good at lying she gives the impression she is not lying when she is totally lying. Mix this in with the fact that her husband, Charlie Kirk lover ("Charlie Kirk was a total pussy" - hey, I didn't say it), also lies about Holmes' lying. Also mix in the fact that Holmes deliberately takes actions to convince people she is ignorant, so we are never certain as to when Holmes absolutely knows something or does not know. Holmes herself makes the faux self-deprecating claim she is stupid, which I take to be absolute bullshit.
This is a shitty thing Fielder and Oppenheim (the directors of the doc) do to the audience, which is to present the information of the doc without much fact-finding - or rather, our reference for facts is Fielder, our straightfaced comedian, who himself is seriously put on trial, in the audience's eyes, in his capacity to be truthful. The doc ends with Seyfried accusing Fielder of softening the doc for Holmes' sake, which claim is not incorrect. Furthermore, the reactions of Seyfried as she is being taken through the process of producing the documentary, feel staged. There's even a moment where we hang out wth Seyfried's ponies, which completely baffles the viewer as to what argument the doc is trying to build.
And, alright - as I pointed out, I'm not a regular filmgoer, so I cannot properly criticize a documentary. But if you edit or stage something, you do so to craft an argument; otherwise, why are you? You can call it a point, a theme, a goal, whatever, it is in fact an intellectual argument and you are trying to communicate some concept to the audience. And the message to the audience is ... ehhh? You can't fully know something?
Again, not a doc watcher, but this strikes me as a shitty documentary, because it undermines what the very structure and form of a documentary are intended to achieve. The issue is not that Seyfried and Fielder re-enact the moments during production; the real issue is that the documentary seems to acquit itself that the shots and interviews it captured can contribute to truth, which is a proposition even fiction does not assert - and fiction I know a lot about. Again, I'm an idiot, so take my viewpoint with a grain of salt.
But if "You Can See Everything" is a shitty documentary, then what is it? Well, it's a work of art, and art happens to have the property - and this property solely belongs to art - of breaking all the rules.
I mean, Oppenheim and Fielder have every right to say, Well yeah it's a shitty documentary, and then they just fold their arms and give you a Nathan-esque stare. There is a point where the goodness and badness of a thing do not matter; what is only worth discussing is what the thing is. Which concept "You Can See Everything" lightly touches on; there is simply a point where Elizabeth can both be a rotten liar and a naive waif, a doe-eyed innocent and a cynical schemer, a money-hungry monster and a mother.
If we can conclude anything about her character, it's that she simply does not care who she is or how people perceive her. As is demonstrated, she genuinely dislikes her punlic perception and how "The Dropout" starring Amanda Seyfried (2022) portrayed her. But not enough to stop her husband from abusing that caricature or, for that matter, creating a deepfake of her (this is real and I barely understood it myself).
Which goes into the second thing we can conclude about Holmes: she is incapable of defending herself. She will lie and evade so long as she understands the consequences of refraining from so, but people lie and dodge because they have something to protect. A man covers his gambling to protect his marriage; a man ducks the altar to protect their way of living; a woman lies to her boss to protect her reputation; people become draft-dodgers to protect their lives. Holmes has no reputation to protect, seeing she allows her husband to caricature her; she has no assets to protect (allegedly), as it all goes to restitution; she has no sense of honor to protect, as we established she feels no guilt; and she has no continuity to protect, because she doesn't believe in history. A person with nothing to stand up for is hardly a person; hence, "You Can See Everything", that is, you see nothing.
This, however, is not entirely true - though Oppenheim and Fielder don't show much of Holmes and Evans' attitude toward raising their children, it is quite evident they love them a lot. Even I strain to believe Holmes had kids in an effort to appear more sympathetic, a true Machiavellian move. Of course, one of the ironies of the documentary is that, though it questions everything else, it does not question the parents' love for their children, which constructs a narrative that, if Holmes has any grounding in reality whatsoever, it comprises her children. So...yeah, it's a little cowardly the documentary depicts this narrative as a fact, while every other narrative is a narrative.
If we take "We Can See Everything" as art - not necessarily fiction, but recorded footage edited to tell a specific story, which technically makes it a documentary, but not really - one of its great artistic attributes is the fantastic dialogue, which is all the more incredible in that none of it is scripted, except possibly Fielder and Seyfried's conversations which certainly felt canned. One of Fielder's peculiar skills which he trained via his peculiar shows "Nathan For You" and "The Rehearsal" is that he is very, very good at asking questions, at not breaking off a line of inquiry, of not seeming like an asshole when asking a question, of not feeling too uncomfortable to ask an uncomfortable question, but also appearing or actually being genuinely empathetic and curious while asking the question. In a sense, Fielder's ability to ask questions is on the same plane as Holmes' ability to project unshakeable, nearly deranged confidence: their absolute sincerity hypnotizes you into giving them the response they want. And their complete conviction generates some incredible conversations.
One of the more jaw-dropping interactions is when Fielder convinces Holmes to actually take out one of the machines Theranos developed. They then have a conversation about what the machine precisely does. Holmes says, This machine can do any kind of test. Nathan forcefully argues, But it was found, with plentiful evidence, that it does not. Nathan pushes and pushes until Holmes says, The machine can do any type of test. Nathan then helps her to the conclusion: The machine, through WiFi, can be programmed to do any kind of test, but it remains to be determined that the machine has the actual chemicals and equipment to do the test. What does this exchange reveal? Nothing, because Fielder excuses Holmes' behavior on the argument that Holmes simply misunderstood the plaint and Holmes can lie about what the machine does next week. But it is astounding how much Holmes can lie, and how badly she can lie, and yet still convince people of her lie because of her unshakeable conviction in her lie.
Another excellent attribute of the film is the masterful comedic editing. One of the instances of the editing that had me dying in a theater (an act of public embarassment I wish I could have avoided) is that the film cuts to a scene with Amanda Seyfried acting as Elizabeth Holmes; it then cuts immediately to Christopher Abbott playing Elizabeth Holmes' husband, who is dead-on in his impression of Bill Evans. The movement from kinda-absurd-and-exaggerated impression of Elizabeth Holmes to Abbott's bang-on realistic impression of Bill Evans, from his voice inflections to his physical mannerisms, had me cackling in tears. Another brilliant bit of editing happens when Seyfried's horse farts.
Another another remarkable attribute of the film is that, in my theater at least, everyone laughed at different parts. This wasn't a "Only I'm laughing at the sex scenes in Poor Things", this was people gut-busting at different scenes, from the front row to the middle to the nosebleeds. I think it's because everything about the film is absurd - its premise, how it was made, the progression of its scenes - that everything in the film is funny, but you will be looking at a random, strange detail in the film and all of a sudden the absurdity of the thing crashes upon you and you just start laughing. I've definitely never seen a film like this before.
But the film is way too long (3 hours), and I would hesitate to watch it again. Elizabeth Holmes is an incredibly interesting subject and I'm quite certain she has some mental disorder, something she is lacking next to most human beings, but the film does not go into depth on the extent of her lies nor on her theory of the world and the people surrounding her. Her partner abusing her image is interesting, but the film doesn't really touch on why he does this, or what he hopes to gain from attempting to create Theranos 2.0 (which saying this alone is enough to make one's skin crawl). It is a film ultimately too indulgent of its subject matter and its strangeness to take a specific direction, though, to be fair, I imagine they had days and days of useless footage, wherein Holmes and Evans carefully dodge any interpretation of their actions they dislike. I would not be surprised if this is the best one can gleam from such a manipulative duo as the Holmes-Evan pair.
Which is another interesting subject, that of Holmes' partner, Bill Evans. I think they are a genuine case of folie à deux, where both of them lie so much that they eventually share in the other's delusions. This is very apparent when Holmes, word for word, repeats at the end of the film what Evans says: that they are always completely on the same wavelength and he knows exactly what she is thinking at any given time. One of the big takeaways from the film is that Bill is equally as manipulative as Holmes, but he, in a sense, is equally as vulnerable as Holmes. The beginning of the film renders him completely naked as he showers. For...why? Why show a cameraperson that? To reiterate, being indifferent to the substance or the meaning of what you show people is tantamount to being indifferent to yourself as a person. Evans really has nothing to show to other people, which is why he is contriving all sorts of things to show to people, for example, his many, many scenes of watching YouTube videos of people explaining basic chemistry. Their relationship is not that of the partners leading by their strengths, but by whose delusion happens to be strongest that day.
I actually kinda hated this movie. I hated that the directors seemed to have given up on the thesis for a film, I hated how their commenting on the film's omissions made the film's omitted omissions (for example, declining to cover Evans' wealth, which is a crucial part of Holmes' life, and the history of herself Holmes tells other people, which is briefly touched on by Holmes' father) all the more glaring, and I hated that it was basically an attempt to rehabiliate two truly awful people who were planning, through the documentary, to scam more people. There is a point you are watching so much unmitigated immorality that it amounts to a viewpoint of hell, which is inherently inhuman. But this reveals something about myself too: I myself do not blush from painting scenes of hell, in fact I love it, because inhumanity tends to inform us of what humanity is, albeit from the inefficient negative argument.
So God bless Fielder, Oppenheim and Seyfried for making a lovely film about two truly awful people who plague this miserable Earth, two people I truly, truly wish no fortune for and no one should, whatsoever, except that Elizabeth Holmes should be able to spend more time with her children, and not use that free time to scam more people. But, to reiterate, fuck them, they are not good people, and may God have mercy on their souls.
Anyway, back to not watching movies.
Postscript
As I re-read this review, I realize I have no actual understanding of Holmes' character; I don't actually know about her stint in Theranos, only that, clear as day in the documentary as in her professional life, this woman lies and lies and lies. I now question the narrative around her motherhood, and I am now even questioning whether I know for a fact she can distinguish big lies and little lies. Like a medium or a televangelist, can someone simply live an entire lie for their life, hoping that, someday, that lie is going to hit big? That seems improbable, but not impossible, and all of life consists of taking risks we'll never fully be confident on.
This all the more increases my dislike for the film, though it's not necessarily on the fault of the filmmakers. The film makes the default assumption that the audience knows Holmes is a liar. But I don't know if that assumption pertains. This film is serious ammunition for Holmes to rehabilitate her image, and it would be very, very, very fucked up if she succeeds, because, as I mentioned, she is literally architecting Theranos 2.0 as we speak, and given the reality America has been undergoing for the last decade I seriously do not believe in humanity's defenses against scams. We, of course, cannot fully prevent scams, but that does not mean we should adjust to living in a world of scams, and we should not let scam artists run free.
So...yeah, this film troubles me; it officially troubles me as a person now, whereas before it troubled me as an intellectual. But it's still such a curious film, audacious, ambitious, but ultimately failing in adding to the sum of human knowledge - but, we must admit, for its three hours we did believe in its powers, through a magic trick of Fielder's.